Project

General

Profile

Actions

Bug #7285

open

Websocket compression mishandling

Added by Hans Vermeer 3 months ago.

Status:
New
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
Target version:
Affected Versions:
Effort:
Difficulty:
Label:

Description

There are a number of problems with the decompression implementation of WebSockets. Firstly, in the example PCAP every individual transaction is comprised of a single frame, which fails (https://github.com/OISF/suricata/blob/089d2b1/rust/src/websocket/websocket.rs#L202) because the buffer is empty and the fin flag is set, therefore the path is never executed and for the same reason its not marked as compressed.

Now the other problem is with the LZ77 sliding window (https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7692#section-7.2.2). In this case the Sec-WebSocket-Extensions negotiate a client_max_window_bits=15, but this is not followed in the decompression, resulting in the situations in the screenshot where blocks of data are missing (only after marking every frame as compressed).
Lastly, it doesn't seem like there is any handling on decompression limits with the DeflateDecoder, despite the default WEBSOCKET_MAX_PAYLOAD_SIZE of size 0xffff (which can be increased by users), 65kb is probably enough to have a decent deflate bomb (it seems the limit is ~1032 * 0xffff ~ 67mb).

A python example that handles the decompression properly:

import zlib

leader = "0000ffff" 
pkts = ["f2768db435304f4eb23435b54c4d4b33324c354e353649334e4a4a31b4303231484a4c360600", "0af17777f771b5354ab1304832324a4d49324e4c4b0600", "820a9a9ba59898a65aa4a6a4261a1ba40100"]
client_max_window_bits = 15
c = zlib.decompressobj(-client_max_window_bits)

for p in pkts:
    print(c.decompress(bytes.fromhex(p + leader)))


Files

example_websocket.pcap (2.82 KB) example_websocket.pcap pcap Hans Vermeer, 09/26/2024 06:30 PM
websocket_fail.png (28.1 KB) websocket_fail.png Hans Vermeer, 09/26/2024 06:39 PM
websocket_fail2.png (36.9 KB) websocket_fail2.png Hans Vermeer, 09/26/2024 06:40 PM

No data to display

Actions

Also available in: Atom PDF