Documentation #6552: doc: add tcp timeout fix to upgrade guide - Suricata - Open Information Security Foundation

Custom queries

8.0.0 Stories
Good First Issues
OISF community

Actions

Copy link

Documentation #6552

closed

doc: add tcp timeout fix to upgrade guide

Added by Thomas Winter about 1 year ago. Updated 2 months ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

Normal

Assignee:

Victor Julien

Target version:

8.0.0-beta1

Affected Versions:

7.0.0, 7.0.2

Effort:

Difficulty:

Label:

Description

I have bisected two git commits that have caused large increases in memory use.

This one https://github.com/OISF/suricata/commit/f2e2576ff4 causes an increase in http.memuse.
4.0.6:

http.memuse                                | Total                     | 61928

7.0.0

http.memuse                                   | Total                     | 2698429

This one https://github.com/OISF/suricata/commit/1dac2467c5 causes a massive increase in tcp.reassembly_memuse such that memory use is almost 6x and the reassembly.memcap is hit causing traffic drops (IPS mode) and throughput reduction.
4.0.6

tcp.reassembly_memuse                      | Total                     | 11128832

7.0.0

tcp.reassembly_memuse                         | Total                     | 63608832

I have not been able to figure out why this increased so much hence I am making this ticket for help.

For these stats I used trex with 1 IP.

sudo ./t-rex-64 --astf -f astf/http_https.py -m 100 -d 230400 -l 100

Files

Download all files

http_https_suri5.pcap (11.9 MB) http_https_suri5.pcap		Thomas Winter, 11/23/2023 12:09 AM
massif.out.3238 (50.3 KB) massif.out.3238		Thomas Winter, 11/23/2023 01:21 AM
massif.out.2298 (91 KB) massif.out.2298		Thomas Winter, 11/23/2023 01:21 AM

Subtasks 2 (0 open — 2 closed)

	Documentation #6640: doc: add tcp timeout fix to upgrade guide (6.0.x backport)	Rejected					Actions
	Documentation #6641: doc: add tcp timeout fix to upgrade guide (7.0.x backport)	Closed	Jason Ish				Actions

History
Notes
Property changes

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Thomas Winter almost 1 year ago

Priority changed from Normal to High

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Victor Julien almost 1 year ago

Status changed from New to Feedback
Assignee changed from OISF Dev to Thomas Winter

It would be good to get a better test case, ideally pcap based. Also, you could use tools like valgrinds massif to try to analyze where the memory use is exactly.

Actions

Copy link Download all files

Updated by Thomas Winter 12 months ago

File http_https_suri5.pcap http_https_suri5.pcap added
File massif.out.2298 massif.out.2298 added
File massif.out.3238 massif.out.3238 added

I've attached massif.out.3238 which is 4.0.6 with ReassembleRealloc at 17.1MB peak.
I've attached massif.out.2298 which is 7.0.0 with StreamTcpReassembleRealloc at 61.7MB peak.
Both were captured with `astf/http_https.py -m 100`.

After flows are closed/timedout, memuse returns to baseline so it is not a leak.

Here are some notes on running trex.

#Download and extract
wget --no-cache --no-check-certificate https://trex-tgn.cisco.com/trex/release/latest
tar -xzvf latest
cd v3.04/

#Create a trex config file
cat /etc/trex_cfg.yaml
- port_limit      : 2
  version         : 2
#List of interfaces. Change to suit your setup. Use ./dpdk_setup_ports.py -s to see available options
#interfaces    : ["enp3s0","enp4s0"] 
  interfaces    : ["br10","br20"] 
  port_info       :  # Port IPs. Change to suit your needs. In case of loopback, you can leave as is.
          - ip         : 192.168.10.100
            #default_gw : 192.168.10.15
            default_gw : 192.168.10.16
          - ip         : 192.168.20.100
            #default_gw : 192.168.20.15
            default_gw : 192.168.20.16

#Update traffic to use single client/server IP
diff astf/http_https.py.orig astf/http_https.py
15,16c15,16
<         ip_gen_c = ASTFIPGenDist(ip_range=["16.0.0.0", "16.0.0.255"], distribution="seq")
<         ip_gen_s = ASTFIPGenDist(ip_range=["48.0.0.0", "48.0.255.255"], distribution="seq")
---
>         ip_gen_c = ASTFIPGenDist(ip_range=["192.168.10.100", "192.168.10.100"], distribution="seq")
>         ip_gen_s = ASTFIPGenDist(ip_range=["192.168.20.100", "192.168.20.100"], distribution="seq")

#IPs are on the local interfaces, NICs are connected to the device running suricata acting as router/gateway
ip addr
8: br10: <BROADCAST,MULTICAST,PROMISC,UP,LOWER_UP> mtu 1500 qdisc noqueue state UP group default qlen 1000
    inet 192.168.10.100/24 brd 192.168.10.255 scope global br10
9: br20: <BROADCAST,MULTICAST,PROMISC,UP,LOWER_UP> mtu 1500 qdisc noqueue state UP group default qlen 1000
    inet 192.168.20.100/24 brd 192.168.20.255 scope global br20

#Run the test
sudo ./t-rex-64 --astf -f astf/http_https.py -m 250

I've attached a packet capture of a trex run with -m 10 for 10 seconds. Packet capture would be too large otherwise, you would need to set a very low reassembly memcap to see it run out with this one. I suspect any tcp traffic should see the increased memory usage eg http(s) transactions.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Thomas Winter 12 months ago

So far I have only seen this issue when using trex and another traffic generator.
Running multiple continuous curl to download large files, I do not see such large memory use.
A difference between the curl transactions is that they end with FIN/ACKs. The trex traffic ends in a RST/ACK.
I can use wget and kill the process to do a RST/ACK and see an increase in tcp.reassembly_memuse

while [ 1 ]
do
wget -o /dev/null -O /dev/null --http-user="user" --http-password="pass" --no-check-certificate http://192.168.10.15/upload_test &
wget_pid=$!
sleep 1
kill -s SIGTERM "$wget_pid" 
done

If wget is not interrupted, I do not see the memory use increase as drastically.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Thomas Winter 12 months ago

The streamingBuffer rework seems to be a red herring. I think it just increased memuse just enough to hit the memcap. There seems to be a large change in usage between 5.0.0 and 6.0.0 - I am performing another git bisect.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Thomas Winter 12 months ago

The cause was this patch c50ef8cc21 ("flow: fix TCP closed default initialization") which increased the timeout for TCP sessions in the closed state which caused flows to hang around longer causing elevated memuse which previously would have decreased much sooner. I'm not sure why I could only see this for sessions closed by RST and not FIN as both should become closed state.

Applying the following config restores the previous behaviour

flow-timeouts:
 tcp:
  closed: 0
  emergency_closed: 0

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Thomas Winter 12 months ago

Feel free to close this now.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Victor Julien 12 months ago

Tracker changed from Bug to Documentation
Subject changed from Large increase in memory after upgrade to 7.0.0 causing traffic loss due to memcap to doc: add tcp timeout fix to upgrade guide
Assignee changed from Thomas Winter to Victor Julien
Priority changed from High to Normal
Target version changed from TBD to 7.0.3